Rothenberg Innovation Initiative Removes Risk, Leaves Lots of Reward
Caltech is a community filled with brilliant minds and good ideas. But sometimes it takes more than good ideas to generate world-changing technologies. Indeed, there is a well-known gap between the lab and the marketplace known as the "valley of death," in which high-risk but potentially high-reward research can languish for want of someone to take a chance on it.
To bridge that gap, Caltech's Rothenberg Innovation Initiative (RI2) was created in 2009 under the guidance of Larry Gilbert, the founding father of tech transfer at Caltech, and funded by the late Caltech trustee Jim Rothenberg and his wife, Anne Rothenberg. RI2 provides competitive grants for early-stage research that could one day lead to marketable technologies that are likely to benefit society. Each RI2 award provides up to two years of support, with up to $125,000 in funding per year, to help researchers "de-risk" their innovations, according to Fred Farina, Caltech's chief innovation and corporate partnerships officer and head of the Office of Technology Transfer and Corporate Partnerships, or OTTCP, which oversees RI2 with Vice Provost Kaushik Bhattacharya. The goal is to help technologies mature beyond the conceptual stage to the point that it is attractive to venture capitalists and other investors.
Originally known as the Caltech Innovation Initiative, the program was renamed in 2017 to honor the Rothenbergs. The Rothenbergs had committed an additional $15 million to ensure the program's ongoing success in March 2015, just before Jim's sudden death in July at age 69.
"It means a lot to our family that Caltech is so committed to RI2," says Daniel Rothenberg, Jim and Anne's son, who is also an active supporter of the RI2 fund. "Caltech has some of the brightest minds, and it is nimble enough to fund projects and see them through. That's why my dad fell in love with the concept of RI2 and supported it. Today, we've had great success thanks in part to the many people who have taken it far beyond our early ideas and even farther beyond the expanded funding our family committed a couple years ago. We want to push to the point where all Caltech faculty and staff have the ability to see their home-run ideas come to fulfillment."
Projects previously funded by RI2 include research by Sarkis Mazmanian, the Luis B. and Nelly Soux Professor of Microbiology and a Heritage Medical Research Institute investigator, who showed a connection between bacteria found in the human intestinal tract and disorders of the central nervous system, such as autism spectrum disorder, Parkinson's Disease, anxiety, and depression. RI2 support allowed Mazmanian to test oral treatments in proof-of-concept animal trials that ultimately attracted venture capital funding, enabling the founding of Axial Biotherapeutics with $19.15 million in funding at the end of 2016.
Caltech faculty can submit one idea per year to the program. Applications are reviewed by a committee consisting of Caltech faculty, members of OTTCP, and members of the venture investment community. Proposals are required to be simple: a maximum of four pages with answers to 12 brief questions, including what the project will be, what milestones can be achieved with RI2 funding, the unmet need in the marketplace, and commercialization plans for the technology.
What makes it work so incredibly well is that "it is the least bureaucratic process that any faculty member has to deal with in terms of raising money for their research," says Richmond Wolf (MS '94, PhD '97), former director of Caltech's Office of Technology Transfer. "What we are looking for is high risk super high return ideas that otherwise might not get funded. We don't ask that you've done two to three years of research already. We ask that you dream about science and engineering that can change the world and yield economic benefit."
The committee is tasked with deciding which promising ideas will receive funding. The RI2 program receives more than 20 proposals every year, of which about a third are funded.
For 2018, eight projects received RI2funding:
- a new method for figuring out which antigens are being targeted by the immune system's T cells. The method—developed by David Baltimore, president emeritus and the Robert Andrews Millikan Professor of Biology—could identify whether those T cells are misfunctioning, potentially leading to autoimmune diseases;
- a system for diagnosing many diseases from just one blood draw, using single-cell messenger RNA profiling of the immune system. The system was created by Sisi Chen, senior research scientist, and Matthew Thomson, assistant professor of computational biology;
- a wearable band invented by Wei Gao, assistant professor of medical engineering, to provide noninvasive monitoringof stress and depressive disorders by tracking changes in sweat;
- a project by Professor of Chemistry Brian Stoltz to develop anticancer drugs from bis-tetrahydroisoquinoline chemicals, natural compounds known for targeting the DNA in cancer cells;
- "Turnkey," a technology that would provide frequency-agile optics on a chip for medical diagnostics, information technology, cybersecurity, and metrology, developed by Amnon Yariv, the Martin and Eileen Summerfield Professor of Applied Physics and Electrical Engineering;
- a project developed by Frances Arnold, the Linus Pauling Professor of Chemical Engineering, Bioengineering and Biochemistry, to engineer enzymes that create amino acids that do not exist in nature for use in pharmaceuticals and as catalysts;
- an ultra-portable three-stage ozone-assisted nano-filtration (ULTRON) device for off-the-grid wastewater treatment, created by Michael Hoffman, the John S. and Sherry Chen Professor of Environmental Science, and Kai Liu, postdoctoral scholar.
- and a low-cost wearable "smart patch" that measures the physiological stress on athletes and patients suffering from chronic health conditions, developed by Axel Scherer, the Bernard Neches Professor of Electrical Engineering, Applied Physics and Physics. Scherer's smart patch is also the inaugural winner of the Hagopian Innovation Prize, established by Caltech Trustee B. Kipling (Kip) Hagopian and his wife, Mary Ann, to support RI2 projects in early-stage research that will enhance economic well-being, quality of health, and longevity in the world at large.
"The RI2 program has generated momentum for innovation at Caltech, and we're determined to build upon that momentum," says Bhattacharya, who is also the Howell N. Tyson, Sr., Professor of Mechanics and Materials Science.
RI2 is just one way that Caltech seeks to promote entrepreneurs on campus. Faculty members with promising marketable research can also apply for up to $75,000 per year in support through the Gates Grubstake Fund, which was established in 1994 by the late Caltech trustee Charles C. Gates Jr. and is also overseen by OTTCP and Bhattacharya.
For 2018, the Grubstake Fund is supporting a collaboration between Mikhail Shapiro, assistant professor of chemical engineering and Schlinger Scholar, and Azita Emami, the Andrew and Peggy Cherng Professor of Electrical Engineering and Medical Engineering—both Heritage Medical Research Institute Investigators—to develop microchips that are aware of their own location and could be used in "smart pills" to diagnose and treat diseases.
Both RI2 and the Grubstake Fund represent Caltech's ongoing effort to ensure that potentially world-changing ideas escape the confines of academia and reach fruition as products and technologies that can change—and sometimes save—lives. The only downside is that not all of the worthy ideas that are submitted can be funded.
"Since we launched this project in 2009, RI2 has become an essential part of technology transfer at Caltech. And, every year, we see many more exciting ideas than the program can support, which means that many excellent ideas never get a chance to prove their commercial potential and show the kind of impact they could have in people's lives if commercialized. That is why it is so important to grow the program," Farina says.
Farina is currently working with Development and Institute Relations to actively raise additional funds to expand the endowment that supports RI2, with the goal of increasing the number of projects it can fund each year.
More information about RI2 and the Grubstake Fund can be found online at http://innovation.caltech.edu/content/ci2 and http://www.innovation.caltech.edu/content/grubstake-fund.
